There is no telling when the Twilight-mania is going to stop. The latest internet buzz is the allegation that the Vatican condemns the movie. These news reports are misleading, first, because Monsignor Franco Perazzolo only expresses his concern over the moral impact of the movie (he does not condemn it nor ask others not to watch it), and second, because the opinion of the Monsignor is not an official Vatican review of the film. He might be a Vatican official but he is not the Vatican. His is but one voice among many in the Church.
If you want to know what Catholic and Christian film reviewers say about the film then this post is for you. Most of the reviews I’ve read offer not only a positive view of the film but also points for reflection. However, some reviewers noticed some concerns as regards the technical, narrative and moral aspects of the film. I encourage you to click on the links to read the full reviews as the quotations might not do justice to the original message of the authors.
- WHEN MONSTERS LOVE by Elisabeth Leitch
Like Edward and Jacob, we too are far from perfect. Within each of us are thirsts for that which we are not meant to consume. In each of our lives are moments in which our anger has gotten the better of us and our ability to love others has seemingly crumbled before our eyes. But as Romans 5:8 reads: “God demonstrates his own love for us in this: While we were still sinners, Christ died for us.” And in the same way that Bella’s similar sacrificial offer speaks to her ability to see Edward as more than just the monster he believes himself to be, so too does Christ’s sacrifice speak to the value within each of us that makes us not only deserving of his love but capable of bestowing that love on others. Read full review… - THE TWILIGHT SAGA: NEW MOON by MovieGuide
The content of NEW MOON includes many positive, moral elements – surprising for a movie about vampires, werewolves, and teenage romance. For example, Bella is willing to give up her life for Edward if that means saving him. Also, Bella and Edward do not let their relationship go any farther than just kissing. Furthermore, Edward consistently refuses to give into Bella’s demands to be turned into a vampire because he is afraid that she will lose her soul and be damned to Hell, although in the end he acquiesces on the condition that she marries him first. Read full review… - THE TWILIGHT SAGA: NEW MOON by John Mulderig
This latest chapter in the love story of well-mannered vampire Edward Cullen (Robert Pattinson) and mortal high school student Bella Swan (Kristen Stewart) is — like its 2008 predecessor “Twilight” — remarkable for the innocence of their interaction. (Edward fears that temptations of the flesh, if indulged beyond the occasional kiss, might give way to temptations of the blood.) What makes it sad is the thought of how rare the portrayal of such a restrained relationship has become, even in entertainment aimed at the young. Read full review… - THE TWILIGHT SAGA: NEW MOON by Fr. Peter Malone, MSC
So, it looks as though New Moon does exactly what it set out to do, please the huge number of readers, provide a female teenage audience with a film that is theirs, and make a case that, despite the Dracula history, there can be some nice and honourable vampires. Read full review… - THE TWILIGHT SAGA: NEW MOON by Thaisha Geiger
While Bella and Edward’s relationship does remain physically chaste, except for a few kisses, their emotional happiness is heavily dependent on one another. Bella’s whole life revolves around Edward. And once he is gone, she repeatedly says she now has no soul or that there’s now a huge hole in her chest. Even though this is fiction, there is a similarity to many current youth who often become emotionally dependent in their relationships and sometimes subconsciously idolize their fallible relationships. Read full review… - NEW MOON: THE TWILIGHT SAGA RETURNS by Steven D. Greydanus
Basically, Bella is obsessive, and Edward is possessive (which, unfortunately, most girls translate into ‘protective’). Bella’s always raving over Edward’s body and how he’s like a ‘god’; Edward’s drawn to Bella’s seductive scent and her blood, and watches her every move, even to the point of watching her in her sleep. Sounds like the common, abusive relationships we have today, minus the vampire aspect, doesn’t it?” Read full review… - ACTION AND HEARTBREAK, NOT ROMANCE, THE FOCAL POINT OF “NEW MOON” by Christa Banister
No matter how much someone suspends his/her disbelief, as one has to do when watching a movie about a vampire romancing a human, it’s still impossible to overlook the fact that we still don’t know what exactly Bella loves so much about Edward (other than his stunning looks) that she’d make that kind of sacrifice (and vice versa, considering the whole vampire/human tension for him) because it never was fully explored. Read full review… - THE TWILIGHT SAGA; NEW MOON by CBCP Cinema
Prejudices among the audience run high. The con-camp says Pattinson with his paler-than-pale skin, lipstick-red lips and dead-pan acting is too wooden to be real; voices from the pro-side claim that’s to be expected of a century-old vampire raised at a time when good manners were in. One side cringes with disappointment at the lack of fantabulous CGI (as may be found in good disaster movies or any Harry Potter sequel); the other side goes gaga over the cool werewolves. Cynics think New Moon is corny and boring; fans think it’s the ultimate high. Read full review…












